Freedom of Speech or Hate Speech?

A new sample of hate, the new movie by an Egyptian Coptic Christian (based in California) titled ‘Innocence of Muslims’ that caused a lot of chaos around the Islamic world.

America champions the freedoms of speech and religion and that makes it a desirable place to live. Having said that, I also believe that with freedom comes responsibility. People should consider sensitivities of the immense diversity existing in this great nation while practicing their right of freedom of speech.

Any irresponsible statement about a person or a group could result in creating suspicion, fear and hate among the masses. Extremism that exists all around, flourishes on it and results in pain at the end. Anti Muslim sentiments in the US are on the rise and being a Muslim, a cause of great concern. A new sample of hate, the new movie by an Egyptian Coptic Christian (based in California) titled ‘Innocence of Muslims’ that caused a lot of chaos around the Islamic world.

On the 11th anniversary of 9/11, while CNN was reporting on its recent poll, 70 percent of Americans have decided to move on from the tragedy of 9/11 (especially after Osama bin Laden is gone) and getting their focus on states of the economy and election; another tragedy struck. Riots broke out in the Middle East in protest of the said movie. The moviemaker’s apparent objective was to offend the feelings of Muslims by ridiculing the Prophet of Islam due to his belief in Islam to be a ‘cancer’. There is no doubt that he is entitled to his opinion, but it was not the case of freedom of speech but rather more of hate speech. And what did hate this result into? More hate, innocent lives lost in Libya including U.S. Ambassador Stevens.

Though the reaction to this hateful film was equally hateful and irrational, the focus should remain on the hate that triggered it. Even if the authorities believe that this kind of reaction in Libya and many other Muslim countries might not be the direct result of this filthy film, there is still need to find the actual cause.

Just last month, hate instigated the killing of innocent Sikhs in Wisconsin and even right after 9/11, a case of mistaken identity.  People need to remember, Islam is the second largest religion of the world and majority does not agree with this kind of violence and bloodshed. Islam is pro-life, pro-moderation, pro-tolerance and pro-human rights and religious freedoms. If some ignorant clerics are misleading and picking the extreme route, then the whole faith should not be judged based on the actions of a few. These incidents are reminders that there is even greater need for interfaith dialogue and awareness.

I am glad that many Muslim leaders took a stance and denounced the unjust killing of fellow Americas as a result of these riots. It was heartwarming to receive notes of concern and disgust from local Christians over the film made to disgrace founder of our religion. As Muslims, we believe that all prophets of God (1,24,000 in total) are equally respectable and an effort to disrespect any one of them is indecent. Discussing blasphemy, the fourth Caliph (world wide spiritual leader) of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community, the late Mirza Tahir Ahmad made it very clear that, “Islam does not advocate the punishment of blasphemy in this world nor vests such authority in anyone.” (Islam’s Response to Contemporary Issues, page 39)

In conclusion, there is absolutely no need of violence to show difference of opinion. Hate is evil and brings out the worst in people. The movie was inappropriate and so was the response to it. We need to remember that at the end, love conquers and hate divides so the hate needs to go.

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Bill Palmer September 25, 2012 at 12:18 PM
Mr. Ahmad manages to take the absurd and totally wrong leap from "responsibility" to "guilt: with the following from his essay: "it was not the case of freedom of speech but rather more of hate speech. And what did hate this result into? More hate, innocent lives lost in Libya including U.S. Ambassador Stevens." We need to understand that much of the Islamic world is 500 years behind the Christian world in practicing the true principles of religion....tolerance, love, etc. And Mr. Amhad needs to cease being a toady for this corrupt and inept Obama regime.
S. Ahmad September 25, 2012 at 12:47 PM
Mr. Palmer, It is time to accept that extremism has no religion. My point is that just like extremist minds in the Islamic world, there are many living right here belonging to other faiths but feeding off and spreading hate and causing hurt. We should unite against extremist minds irrespective of faith and not target once particular group because of a few bad apples. I admit that some Muslims have taken the extreme route but you need to understand that its their fault not an inherent property of this religion whose mere name means 'peace' and which teaches love and tolerance. This is why reaction from fellow Muslims was a great disappointment and loss of innocent lives was sad but the cycle of hate is destructive and needs to stop. My community, the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community bears the motto: Love for all, hatred for None and we strive to live by it since hate never solves anything. Please visit www.muslimsforpeace.org for more information.
Michael k September 26, 2012 at 12:11 AM
@Bill Palmer - sell crazy someplace else, we're all stocked up here.
James Coaltrain September 26, 2012 at 11:31 AM
M. Ahmad, the world press should publish a cartoon a week that depicts Mohamed in some fashion or another. If you look around Christianity is ridiculed daily here in the USA, Islam being just another religion will be ridiculed in the same fashion from time to time. It is not hate to depict a religious figure as a buffoon or worse, it is the standard operating practice of the many atheists that live here in our country. The Muslim's need to "get over it" your religion is no more sacred than Catholic, Baptist, Mormon, Amish etc. The "we will murder you if you show a picture of Mohamed" is so 17th century it dates your entire culture. Get over it, quit killing people for "disrespecting" Mohamed, and quit killing people because they are not Muslim. In other words grow up and join us in the 21st century. Have a nice day!
Ahmad September 27, 2012 at 07:00 PM
I didn't know disregarding mutual respect , feelings and emotions makes someone of 21st century.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »